Must-flee TV
Adam Murray, writing for TVSquad.com says:
Burnim-Murray Productions and October Moon Television are attempting to sell a new comedy game show for syndication. The series, called Laugh Off, would give unknown comedians a chance to compete in different contests centered around stand-up, improv, charades and mime.
We’re troubled by many things.
Firstly, the art accompanying the article is a photo of a braying horse. We suspect that they couldn’t find a stock photo of an actual jackass. It was an editorial decision by someone at TVSquad, no doubt, who figured that a boring shot of a comedian holding a microphone in front of a brick wall didn’t suit the copy.
Second, what is Burnim-Murray and October Moon’s idea of “unknown comedian?” That could be anyone from Jim Gaffigan to the guy at the water cooler who cracks us all up with his dead-on impression of Jim From Taxi! You know how these TV producers look at the world!
Third, why does everyone feel compelled to muck things up with improv, charades and mime? (We suppose that pitches are getting ever more tricky these days. It’s gotta be “fresh” and “new,” but it also must be derivative and downright larcenous. What you end up with is something that’s vaguely familiar, superficially inventive and hardly exciting. Rather like thoroughbred horse breeding– each new horse must be able to trace his bloodline back to a previous champ– but the resultant increase in speed over the past century hardly seems worth all that fussing and is far, far less than what you’d expect.)
Charades?!! Invite Buddy and Sally over! We’re going to play charades!! How do you feel about Adlai Stevenson? This baked Alaska is scrumptious!! Is this irony? We fear it is not.
4 Responses
Reply to: Must-flee TV
How about a contest where people just perform stand-up comedy?How about a contest where people just perform stand-up comedy??How about a contest where people just perform stand-up comedy???Dammit, how about a contest where just people perform stand-up comedy????
<>“Charades?!! Invite Buddy and Sally over! We’re going to play charades!! How do you feel about Adlai Stevenson? This baked Alaska is scrumptious!!<>If there’s going to be fondue, I’m all over it!
The seven or eight people who did not appear on National Lampoon’s Funny Money but actually saw it, may recall that we limited the comic’s activities to… stand up comedy (notwithstanding the reasonably dignified “picture captioning” round). Truth be told, we experimented with many of he same elements as this show when were in development. We tried the heckling thing, improv prop stuff, even talk show style couch interviews. As a producer on that show and a veteran of a couple of Star Search comedy appearances, I can tell you that ultimately stand up just isn’t a competitive thing. Like jazz, when the artist is “in it,” they shouldn’t be worried about getting their ass kicked by someone more “in it.” I can’t watch LCS and I’m sure this one will be just a cringe producing – no disrespect to the participants, just the circumstances.
Star Search, at least in its early seasons, was pretty successful at having a “competition” among comics and many made an impact, even in defeat.I hear what you’re saying about being “in it,” but exactly how many comics can actually achieve that under the artificial conditions of a TV taping?