Dan Hirshon is a Brandeis Univeristy student
studying abroad in South Africa. He recently jumped
at the chance to go onstage in Cape Town, South Africa.
I used to think Maine was a foreign country. After my
one and only trip from Boston to Portland, ME, I was sure I’d
seen my last days of driving hours just to bomb at a
five-minute open mike spot. Now, after an eighteen-hour
flight across the world, I’m testing material on my first
South African audience. I'm thinking I’ll do just about anything
for stage time.
Boston is a supportive comedy community. They never miss
a chance to provide constructive criticism. Before liftoff
to the Cape Town I’m instructed, "apartheid jokes are hack"
and "The HIV/AIDS bit probably won’t fly." Luckily,
I’m not an insensitive racist, so only half of my set has to
be cut.
I arrive. I call and book a spot at the club. I freak.
What if they don’t understand the words that are coming out
of my mouth? Have they heard of ecstasy? What about
junior high school? And pubic hair? That’s the staple of my act.
Is there a South African equivalent to this material? Will I
have to find a substitute word to describe my curlicue hairdo?
Two weeks pass and I’ve finally got a date for Cape Town’s
Comedy Warehouse. Thank God. I’ve getting fed up with working
inanimate bedroom crowds. My pillow and sheets are starting
to know my act inside and out and I don’t think they were
all that amused to begin with.
Outside my door, my housemates must think I’m
the bastard child of Andy Kaufman and Virginia Wolff.
Tuesday is Open Mike Night. My American housemates are here
to support. The only fear that terrifies me more than a
silent crowd is the distinct echo of my housemates’ forced
laughter piercing an otherwise silent crowd. Well, it’s
the thought that counts.
Joe Parker, the comedy club owner, is here tonight.
Luckily our taxidriver is running according to African time,
showing up 45 minutes late. I’m all about first impressions...
and pathetic excuses. Stepping in, I see the Comedy Warehouse
doesn’t just talk the talk. It’s the Kmart of humor,
what I would’ve imagined Noah’s Ark to resemble, except there
is no crazy 600 year-old geezer barking outside, pleading
for two of every kind to come watch tonight’s comedy. I’m used
to bars and speakeasy gigs, stages made of broken tables
and crates, crowds varying in number from six to thirty, depending on
how many drunks decide to engage in obnoxious conversation
during my set. Running a long hall of stadium seating,
the warehouse resembles blueprints for a Roman Basilica.
I feel like I’ll be addressing Parliament or a church congregation.
A rowdy and raucous horde of 250 surround and strangle the
long stage like a python. Massive pillars slice
through the center aisle, supporting the ceiling and successfully
obstructing the views of the buzzed and baked upstairs,
whose vision is probably already blurry. The culture
and the language barrier won’t be the only new feature for
tonight.
Apparently it’s Axess night. Axess appears to be some
privileged society out of Durban that only the hippest youth
can join if they pay for the Axess card. Music videos
play on the theater-size movie screen on stage and a
random motorcyclist stunt man to races up the entrance
ramp and along the center aisle of the Warehouse.
How am I gonna top MTV and Evil Knievel?
Pacing through the bar, diving around trays, drinks, and irritated
waitresses, I contemplate another bathroom visit, but soon find
my trip postponed by the host’s welcoming introduction.
"Your next comedian is all the way from the states,
but don’t hold it against him. Give it up for DAN!!!"
The audience laughs, and then holds it against me. There are
two things South African comedy goers love to hate-- Australian
athletes and the American government. If George W. played
cricket in Sydney these guys would probably assassinate him.
There’s a good deal to hate America for, according to an
audience member who later approached me. I’m sure he could have
begun the history lesson earlier, but in 1975 or so,
the U.S. abandoned South African troops in Angola. Then
there was apartheid. America had put the most
money, for the longest period of time, into South Africa,
to ensure that the Communists didn’t take over. When the U.S. finally decided to pull their financing, apartheid
crumbled and a lot of rich, white people
quickly saw their country club lifestyles crumble. Most of these
rich, white people often attend comedy shows. In addition,
the impact of 9/11 didn’t hit Cape Town exactly the way
it hit in the States. Some comics even tell me they wrote material
about the plane crashes the night it happened. Eventually
I’m graced with some of this material. Another comic,
Riaad Moosa, joking about the situation in Afghanistan asks,
"Why would they bomb a country that looked the same before
the way as it did after the war."
South Africans are even less enthusiastic about the situation
in Iraq, and many posters can be found,
supporting Saddam as less of a threat than George W.
My legs become cast iron, pounded into the stage. My
uncomfortable laugh meets uncomfortable silence. Despite
endless bedroom rehearsals and comedy workshops in the shower
I have little to show for Cape Town material. How do you
write jokes for a culture of English, Afrikaaners, Blacks, Indians,
Coloreds, and closet bigots? Do they like each other
or do they hate each other? What’s funny? What’s offensive?
Why should I care? Does any of this really matter? About 145
of the 150 people in the audience are of the rich, white,
upper class anyway. Hundreds of eyes float in the dark around me
like those Loony Tunes cartoons where you can only see
two black pupils sticking out through the dark. My cast iron
legs melt to Jell-O. If only Bill Cosby were here to help.
I'm at a loss as to figure out another way to start my
set and I'm culture shocked by the room. I throw out my
big opening line. "Heyyy, everybody,
check it out, I’m a stupid American." (For every line
that sounds funny in my head, I can recall a disaster onstage.
I prove, over and over again, the importance of trying bits
out loud before performing them for grandstands filled
with people.) Luckily my regular five minutes of
rants about family and the fortunes of my gene pool
are sufficiently funny to get some laughs. Settled in, I end on
a decent note with a cheap joke that I’ve South Africanized.
It’s amazing how a bit about "the name game" can
get laughs just about anywhere in the world. I’m not sure
about Antarctica though.
After a barrage of U.S. political and celebrity impersonations
from the other comedians, I realize that I must have befuddled
the audience being an American without a sluggish
Texan accent or suave Hollywood persona. Flooded by CNN and
overseas sitcoms, South Africans seem to be under the impression
that everyone in the United States either spends his entire day
in a coffee shop with five of his best friends or else bombs
the adopted country of wealthy terrorists with too much
facial hair.
As I slink offstage,
Joe gives me key advice: "The jokes were okay, you seemed
confident. Just try to localize the set more." My friends
inundate me with slightly more comforting yet idiotic remarks
soon after. "Wow, you were great. I thought you
were the best comedian tonight. None of the other comedians
were very funny." I especially like "Their
jokes didn’t make any sense. They were stupid."
So it goes when half the punchlines are told in Afrikaans,
a language derived from Dutch and other languages.
During the reign of the National party and apartheid,
Afrikaans prevailed over English among South Africans. Today,
it’s not unusual to find Afrikaans sprinkled through the
material of most comedians here. Even traces of tribal
dialects like Xhosa sometimes pop and click up. While my
friends waste hours studying foreign
language, I’m learning how to say, "Your mother’s
a pussy" in three different languages. Walking out
the door, I secure two more gig dates, Friday and next Tuesday.
Hopefully I’ll have my native tongue sorted out by then.
My mind wanders as I attempt to localize my set. Somehow
I find time to enroll in classes at the University
of Cape Town. Contrary to the beliefs of friends back home,
none of my classes are taught by Bushmen, and spears
are not provided in lieu of a meal plan. However, UCT
is the king of kings for fitness and bodybuilding since
the main campus is located on a mountain. "You know
you’re taking a challenging course load when your daily hike
to school is a thirty-minute climb up a place called
"Devil’s Peak." So far so good. Now for some
more material. "With the brutal summer heat of February,
I sweat oceans while walking up the mountain."
"Whales migrate to me. I have my own aquarium and seafood
restaurant. I have wave pools and waves of girls... moving
away from me." "I’m planning on selling my sweat
to buy an escalator for the school." "The 300 stairs
just aren’t doing it for me. It’s like stairway to heaven.
By the time you reach the top, you’re dead. Even Rocky,
champion of the world, couldn’t handle it. "Yo, Adrian,
I know I’m training and all, but this is bullshit."
"Driving isn’t much of an option on campus with the current
parking situation. I had to park in Mozambique before walking
to class."
Working through more material, I realize how much I miss
public transportation. The Green Line on the Boston subway,
known as the "T," offered immaculate train cars
running every five minutes taking me anywhere
for a buck. Inspiration for new material is everywhere.
Cape Town’s equivalent
to mass transportation is a road reckless minivan that’ll grab
you on Main Road and spit you out whenever you’re re-tasting
your breakfast. Overstuffed by about 30 people, the van feels
more like a mosh pit than a taxi ride, and I’m fairly certain
that none of the three Rand (40 cents) I toss the driver
goes toward gear replacements or car washes. I miss the
Boston nightlife as well.
Not the $30 clubs and the $5 beers as much as
the safety and security I felt walking around Boston at night.
Here, several of my friends have been mugged just
outside our house and others have been pick-pocketed,
swindled and/or chased throughout town.
With magnetic barbed wire fences and several gated doors around
my place, I find myself carrying eighty or ninety keys just to
reach my room in this high-security prison. Clinking
and clanging around, like maracas in my pocket.
And this is supposedly laid back compared to Johannesburg.
"Crime just ain’t what it used to be. It’s not like
taking candy from a baby since even the babies are ripping
you off."
"The security is no help either. Decked
out in gray khakis, carefully sewn sweaters, and highly polished
shoes, these guys look more like catalog models than protection.
The average guard seems to be five feet tall with a
twenty-four-inch waist. I don’t know who’s idea it was to
recruit at the circus, but I think the bearded lady would’ve
been more effective than the midgets and munchkins."
"I’ve already gotten a taste of how these guys work.
The other day four hoodlums threw me against the wall,
demanding everything I owned. Suddenly security came to
the rescue." "Freeze!" "Who the hell
are you?" "I represent the lollipop guild,
the lollipop guild, the lollipop guild."
So there’s
the new routine: UCT, public transport, and security.
Not a shabby set list. It’s Friday. Showtime.
Cokey Falkow rips into the cordless mike, introducing himself
as the host for tonight. Actor, filmmaker, radio personality,
surfer, and national headliner, Falkow is the Leonardo de Vinci
of South African Comedy. His carefree surfer cut packs neatly
beneath a baseball cap that he slaps sideways. With a twisted
love for American pop, Falkow’s undone jean jacket exposes
his T-shirt’s testimonial statement, "Avril Sucks."
He later makes himself comfortable, removing the jacket
and revealing that "Brittany Swallows."
His tattooed forearms and long metal chain run from pockets
to knees, parallel with his baggy jean pants that overflow
across his skater shoes. Upon charging the platform,
Falkow is morphed further into cartoon-hood. His spastic
twitches juxtaposed with unusual voice effects pose
the question of whether he suffers from schizophrenia,
Tourette’s or both. His brain stretches like silly putty,
pulling and placing puns in between every breach imaginable.
Only occasionally, however, does Falkow seem to tell an actual
joke. Sometimes
the crowd is there. Sometimes the silent room reeks of
brain-fart. Falkow doesn't falter in either case.
Like many other South African comedians in the
"alternative" scene, Falkow is concerned with edge
and outlook, not easy laughter. While this doesn’t raise
eyebrows in the U.S. or U.K., the alternative mentality is still
new in South Africa, just like the fall of apartheid.
The link between the two is more than coincidental.
Time for my set. I’m suddenly met by the heavy distortion
of Blur’s "Song 2" exploding through the ceiling
speakers in surround sound. They’ve given me my own theme music.
I feel like a WWE wrestler, just a bit bigger. I start
with my string of university mountain jokes, which break
the ice nicely. Even audience members who haven’t taken
classes at UCT have seen the mountain, and my helpless self
becomes a good time had by all. The minibus bit falls flat
and seeps through the floor. The security guard material
chases it down like bad tequila, so I flip back to impersonating
my family on a good day. Ah, old material is so comforting
yet so unsatisfying. If only I could write five great new minutes
a night. I’d become a South African legend within a month.
I end with "name game" and thank the audience
for being so wonderful tonight. A local comic,
Paul "Snoddy" Snodgrass is waiting for me
at the bar. "No one’s heard of Wizard of Oz here.
The ‘lollipop guild’ gag was funny, but they don’t know
what you’re talking about." "What about
the minibus stuff?" "Hack. Overdone. They’ve
probably just heard it before. Minibuses have awful drivers.
They’re all over crowded, dirty and dangerous. Most guys
here could probably come up with 20 minutes just off that."
"So what else is hack?" "It’s different
for you. You’re giving your perspective from the States.
Of course its gonna be new for you. But if you do it for
a couple years here you get all this material over and over,
about car guards and stupid Australians, black guys steal
and have no teeth. A lot of it’s just racist. Alternative
comedy’s only been going for a couple years here, but
already there’s South African hack topics." I need
more explanations and I soon get them.
In the balcony office overlooking the Warehouse, I
relive flashbacks and seek explanations.
Dimly lit by desk lamps, it's like a police interrogation
room-- some are in the light, some in the dark,
and some amongst shadows. Falkow moves in and out of
the shadows, waiting for the tomato sauce that he
plans to send drown his fish and chips in. Snoddy
and Al Prodgers, a headliner from Johannesburg, sit nearby.
Falkow leans forward and the three comedians begin talking
stage history. Alternative comedy for South Africa
started in 1970’s England. England?
South Africans didn’t watch standup in the States
till later. English comedians were experimenting
with observational and improvisational humor. And
the ‘guy walks into a bar,’ gag comics weren’t
getting the big gigs anymore. From there the memo
for new comedy trickled down to Johannesburg and eventually
to Cape Town. The end of apartheid and the elections
in 1994 made it all possible. Prodgers says, "Before,
you could get killed for saying the wrong thing,
but now you can say what you want."
"Younger comics
started leaving the mainstream-- the racist and sexist
jokes-- jokes that got passed around for everyone to use.
You got guys like John Vlismas, Sean Briggs,
and Alyn Adams constantly writing new material, comic
monologues, observational humor.
"John Vlismas
was the reason I got into comedy," Snoddy tells me.
"In 1998 a couple of us at Cape Town University
got together and opened a venue in the basement of
Barney’s." Soon after, things began rolling.
The Cape Comedy Collective soon formed and in March
2001 Joe Parker opened the Comedy Warehouse.
"More new clubs were opening. The old guys
were working with new. Sometimes it’d be like having
Bob Hope and Bill Hicks doing the same room.
It wasn’t always pretty. Five years ago an open
miker was told to go out and learn as many jokes
as they could. Now you got guys writing their own
material and they do it so well you can’t
steal it if you wanted to. Guys are either
changing their material or moving to the background.
But different audiences are bringing different
responses. Sometimes I gotta do a gag about
Australians or rip on the tourists to get the crowd on my
side cause that’s what they’re still used to.
Likewise, some black comics think that they have to
characterize and play to their stereotypes to get the
laughs. I’ve seen black comics do just as well,
challenging those stereotypes. It can be
like performing heart surgery with a chainsaw,"
says Prodgers. "We’re giving them a glimpse at something
new."
Joe Parker has a different take on the situation.
"People politicize comedy too much," he argues.
"It’s not about making a moral stand. Audiences here
aren’t biased toward traditional or alternative comedy.
They just come here to laugh and that’s what I make
them do."
Initiated into comedy in Port Elizabeth, 1971,
Parker first played guitar parodies in the Navy, eventually
hosting events and moving into standup. After over 30 years
in comedy he draws from both the old and the new comedy
and is still dealing with some of the changes in the scene.
Once government censorship ended, the limitations of
political correctness began. According to Parker’s
website "ever-anal press critics may have difficulty"
with his "cheeky defiance of all things politically
correct." He explains, "White comics are typically
expected to have a box, limiting what they can say. Anybody
should be able to perform what they want. Hanging onto
separate cultures is what keeps us divided, but when we joke,
confront stereotypes, apartheid, we’re involving all
races."
Changing the subject to my set, Joe sounds positive.
"You got a lot of material that you could do anywhere
you go," he tells me. "That’s what a lot of comics
here are missing. Their stuff is very South African-oriented.
If you watch guys at the Smirnoff Comedy Festival, they’re
making it happen because they’re writing bits that can be
pulled off anywhere. You know, everyone can laugh at your jokes
about childhood cause you act dorky."
"Thank you," I think.
"Well that’s how you make yourself out to be."
"Thank you." Whatever I’ve got, I use it. I guess
getting beat up from ages 8 to 16 was a godsend after all.
I’m sure there could have been a better alternative, but God
works in mysterious ways. Because of Him, I have material I can
do not only in Cape Town, South Africa, but even as far away
as Bangor, Maine.
|