P.C. : The comic's worst enemy?
From an interview with Tommy Tiernan that appeared on Irish Echo Online, on bringing his “often controversial brand of humor” to U.S. audiences:
“During the last tour, I performed in New York, Nebraska, Texas, Pennsylvania, Sacramento San Francisco and Washington DC,” he said.
“I don’t know if Nebraska and Pennsylvania are Republican states, but the idea that I had about them was that they were and I thought they were going to be conservative America, you know? And I actually found they were incredibly tolerant of my stuff. They struck me as people who worked hard during the week and just wanted to have a laugh. They didn’t really care what you were talking about, had no notion of political correctness or anything like that and if you said something funny, irrespective of the what it was about, they’d laugh.”
Californian audiences, he said were “a little bit prissy.”
“Yeah you know, I found them slightly more…it was kind of as if they wanted to appear to be at the vanguard of all progressive thinking,” he said.
“That was more like auditioning my material for a board of directors in some huge ideological factory.”
We have long maintained that Political Correctness is the comic’s worst enemy.
We might try to catch Tiernan next month, as he hosts the O’Comics Gala (co-hosting with Ed Byrne) in Montreal at the Festival Just For Laughs.
No Responses
Reply to: P.C. : The comic's worst enemy?
From watching Mr. Tiernan’s recent Letterman effort and a warmup set for same at Gotham, I’d say the California audiences may have just found his routines about Irishmen being drunks tedious.
Jeff Caldwell: Having never seen Mr. Tiernan, we can’t say. However, being a comic, you might know that the producers of Late Show routinely allot 4 minutes and 30 seconds to a comedian appearing on that show. And, being a comic, you might know that Mr. Tiernan’s sets for his California audiences were, by necessity, longer (perhaps 10 to 15 times longer or more) than the 4 minutes, 30 seconds he is allotted for his Letterman appearance. And, being a comic, you might also know that Mr. Tiernan probably chose his material for his television appearance (which you characterize as “Irishmen being drunks”) using radically different criteria than that which he might employ in choosing which material to use for his live appearances here in America, owing to time constraints, the FCC, the wishes of the show’s producers, etc. And, being a comic, you might cringe at the thought of someone judging your entire output on the basis of a 4:30 set on a network television show and the 4:30 warmup version of same onstage at Gotham. Or, having seen his Letterman set and read the above article, you might at the very least be somewhat curious as to how his club set might differ from his television set. And, being a comic, you might give Mr. Tiernan the benefit of the doubt. You might. Then again, you might not.