Smoking… in PUB-lick
This just in from Bismarck’s News Leader, KFYR-TV (Is that pronounced, “KAY-fire?” We hope so.)– Ron White has been busted. For smoking. In public.
Here’s the heart of the story, with a typo:
A plainclothes police officer saw him on smoke a cigar on stage.
The officer went to the show after the department received a letter saying that White commonly smokes while he performs.
Who? We say WHO ratted out Ron White? Which busy body was so concerned that the smoke from White’s cigar would sully the Belle Mehus?
It reminds us of Lenny Bruce being monitored by local law enforcement for obscenity. Officers, sometimes summoned by local judges or church officials or garden variety busybodies, would hunker down in the back of the house with a notepad. Ready to spring and bring the show to an end when just enough offensive evidence had been gathered. It happened only a handful of times. The stories are harder to believe as time passes.
My, how times have changed. Now we have militant anti-smokers assailing popular comedians because they… smoke!
We wonder: What would the producers of a play at that facility do if the script called for one of the characters to smoke? Would insipid no-smoking laws take precedence over art? If so, what sense does that make? What if the script called for fire eaters? A man juggling flaming clubs?
Doesn’t Cosby smoke cigars during his sets? George Burns did, right? We seem to recall that Alan King did as well.
Comics take note: A surefire path to “rebel” status– start smoking cigars onstage.
2 Responses
Reply to: Smoking… in PUB-lick
I thought most states (though apparently not ND) did have an exception for being part of a performance — such as the hypothetical play you discuss.
I was on the road somewhere (damn if I can recall where) and the bar down the street was having “Live Theater” night, which was a avant-garde play where the audience became the cast, and improv’ed a play all night. No one gave a shit about the play, of course, but they were trying to use that as a legal loophole to let people smoke.
According to this case, Curious Theater v. Colo. Dept. of Public Health, from March of last year, there are 19 states which have smoking bans that do not have exceptions for stage performances. And other states that do have exceptions.
The Curious Theater Company challenged the law on First Amendment grounds, and the Appellate Court actually agreed that smoking on stage is an expressive act (meaning, it is speech).
But they upheld the Colorado law because it was not specifically intended to restrict free speech, and there were “reasonable” alternatives for theater companies, like fake cigarettes and fake pipes. The Court said that since audiences know that much of what they see on stage is obviously fake (like murders!), they don’t need to see people really smoking.
Well, at least Ron White can afford the $100 North Dakota fine. The day Ron White smokes a fake cigar on stage, standup comedy will die just a little bit.