Last Comic Standing on the Queen Mary
April Macie GONE! Stella Stolper GONE! But first…
Clark tells them that there’ll be a “Head to head competition between three comics…” Wouldn’t that be “head to head to head?” Maybe?
Lots of fat jokes. Those are always great! Dontcha think?
Stella Stolper tries gamely to introduce some spice into the reality television proceedings by being mean and vindictive! You know, nothing endears you to a television audience like mean and vindictive. It’s fun to watch, you know? And she’s about to give birth, so that gives the meanness a special sort of… poignance? Is that the appropriate word?
The Gypsy Lady? You remember the Gypsy Lady from the last Last Comic Standing. Apparently, she has such a good manager that her contract stipulated that her tired, sorry ass be used in perpetuity. She is, however, more animated and likeable than Anthony Clark.
The point of the heckling exercise, says Clark, is to see “who can dish it out and who can take it.” Don’t the clubs have bouncers that pretty much make this point moot? At least the better clubs do. Why not just have the comics do a hell gig somewhere in Fresno or Victorville? At least spare the comics from the ignominy of having to heckle another comic. Through this exercise, the contestants run the risk of having the audience view them all as pathetic, desperate individuals, incapable of saying “no” to even the most shameful requests. (Actually, after seeing the heckling challenge, there is no risk. They have demonstrated it quite clearly.) Oh, it’s all in good fun, you say.
Good for Joey Gay for refusing to take the bait for staying silent when asked to heckle April Macie.
Were there better ways of dreaming up challenges that didn’t subject comedians to this kind of degradation? Certainly. Why they were beyond the imagination or obscured by the prejudices of the producers of the show is inexplicable.
Comics: The next time you get heckled by some loser who thinks he’s “helping out the show,” you may have Last Comic Standing to thank.
As Clark announces the “winner” of the Heckler Challenge (“Winner” is such a relative term in this case), he says, “People… were… crying.” Yes, Anthony, people were crying– the many club owners who were watching their livelihoods quite possibly being destroyed before their eyes… the comedians watching at home who were witnessing the dignity of standup comics in general being shredded in excruciating slow motion on this steaming pile of shit that NBC calls a show. Yes, Anthony, people… were… crying.
“At this stage of the game,” says Chris Porter, “Immunity is everything.” Really? At this stage of the game, a comic can depend on his material to get by. Oh, heaven forbid comics might be depending on a skill that they’ve acquired, and have been honing incessantly, over the last 15 years or so. Oh, the horror that some comic might be required to go on a stage, with a mike, in front of a crowd and make them laugh harder than the other comic who just went up. Gee! That’s too much like… every Friday or Saturday night for the last 15 years or so. How perfectly terrifying that would be! (We aren’t off base here when we say that we might actually speak for every real comic when we say that we’d sit out every immunity challenge that came along just for the opportunity to battle another comic at actually performing! What moron wouldn’t want to take advantage of every opportunity to do his act on primetime network television?)
We’re beginning to think that the show is called Last Comic Standing because, eventually, we’re all going to be out of the business. We’ll all be gone. No one will want to watch standup, live or otherwise. Eventually there will be only one… last… comic… standing.
The previews of next week show some asshole at a radio station yelling (presumably at the comics) “Be funny!” Sorta reminds us of a typical Friday morning when we’re in a station to pump that weekend’s shows. Although, there isn’t usually someone yelling “Be funny!” And, if there is, it’s usually the most hated guy at the station. (One of the worst commands a comedian can get is “Say something funny.” Usually issued by a total tool. It’s the fastest way to get a comic to shut down..)
We’re speechless. At least now we are.
No Responses
Reply to: Last Comic Standing on the Queen Mary
I was watching this tonight and as they were explaining the challenge to the comics I leaned over and told my girlfriend–“I wouldn’t do it. I wouldn’t heckle another comic. Zingers off stage, sure…but to sit in an audience and encourage the type of behavior that we all struggle with–the concept that this <>helps<> the comedians? Nope. Immunity isn’t worth it.”So, when Joey Gay didn’t heckle April Macie…I respected that. I wouldn’t have guessed that anyone on the show would have felt the same way that I did…but he did… I understand that others are playing the game the way it is set up to be played–and that’s all well and good, I don’t think anyone should have felt FORCED to not heckle…I mean, I understand, at some level, why are you on the show if not to play the game they’ve set up for you? But it’s good to know that you can play the game and still have respect…for the journey and for the others who share the path with you.Props to Joey Gay.pgreyy–seattlePS–I admit, I laughed at a couple of the zingers. I thought Kristen Key was quick on her feet with the comebacks (hard earned quickness, from what she described as her nightly experience.) But the “People…were…crying” line from Anthony Clark hit me the same way it hit you, SheckyMag… That wasn’t comedy–that was simply combat. Some audiences like that…but some audiences would like cockfighting too…
Why NBC?Kuddos to Joey Gay-we can all agree on that. My main concern (and there are many) is why does NBC continues to perpetuate the stigma that female comedians are not funny? You’re telling me that out of all the female comedians they auditioned, these are the best ones to represent us????? A black women with great confidence and attitude that talks about her weight ( Nell Carter ring a bell?). An Italian woman with a tough “not taking any shit” philosphy (they threw in the “pregnancy thing” so you wouldn’t confuse her with former LCS Tammy Pescaltelli). April Macie who physicially speaking, everything about her seems to be fake: boobs (I would say breasts but those are definitely boobs), hair, blinding white teeth and highly overexaggerated facial expressions to try and further a punchline that’s weak to begin with. Thank God for Michelle Balen (sp) and Kristen Key!Maybe the real reason why the real funny women aren’t on this show is because they have the smarts not to do it. They realize NBC can’t handle real funny women unless they are getting a pie tossed in their face!
Sure, the heckling nonsense is about as hack as it gets — maybe Don Rickles is a producer? But the one thing I couldn’t get past is Anthony Clark’s suit — his pants are so long, he looked like the kid at the end of “Big.” Also, Shecky deserves props for pointing out the shameless “sweetening” the producers are doing to make it sound to the TV audience like the studio audience is laughing their asses off. Last night’s three competitors put out fairly weak material, but the laugh track and the cut-aways — possibly from a real show somewhere else — made it look impossibly hysterical. Reality TV, my ass.
I agree…the format of the hecklathon was brutal…that said…A challenge tailor made for more intense comedians. Bil Dwyer was not going to win this one. Gabriel Iglesias (sp) gave a psychologically brilliant take…be the big laugher that disrupts the show…you stay likeable, but the effect is the same. However, it didn’t address the point that part of the test was how witty you could be on your feet. And those on-the-feet-witty people did well. Roz’s overpowering performance doesn’t count here because she just steamrollered the entire act, as opposed to try to pick it apart.At first I thought “OK, this show is really about trying to find the next sitcom star, so what does this prove?” But, interestingly enough, those on-their-feet witty people may have shown how readily they could contribute to the script of a sitcom. They came up with something funny immediately under extreme pressure. Sounds like a great skill set for a sitcom writer/performer.Thanks for playing,Jay
Get-R-Done…
I think they should have given Joey Gay immunity for having the class to explain that heckling was wrong and he wanted no part of it. As far as I’m concerned, he won that round by taking the moral high ground.I’m surprised that nobody challenged Josh Blue. Sure, it’d be really hard to beat someone who can gather audience sympathy, but that’s exactly the point– strategically, nobody ELSE would challenge him, and therefore they wouldn’t get challenged back, and thus guarantee staying in the house for at least one more show (sure, they wouldn’t get to perform, but they’d stay on TV longer).